After reading contradictory answers, I decided to make some tests to determine what the correct way to add (2 x 8 GB) RAM to existing (2 x 4 GB) RAM. And this are the results I found.
Tested on iMac (27-inch Mid 2011) Intel Core i7 - 3.4 Ghz with High Sierra:
- With the following configuration from System Information / Memory (by BANK): ***
BANK 0/DIMM0: 4 GB - DDR3 - 1333 Mhz
BANK 1/DIMM0: 8 GB - DDR3 - 1333 Mhz
BANK 0/DIMM1: 4 GB - DDR3 - 1333 Mhz
BANK 1/DIMM1: 8 GB - DDR3 - 1333 Mhz
Geekbench 4 shows and memory bandwitdh at 8.76 GB/sec for Single-Core and 8.61 GB/sec for Multi-Core
(Full results at : https://browser.geekbench.com/v4/cpu/101...)
- With the following configuration System Information / Memory (by DIMM): ***
BANK 0/DIMM0: 4 GB - DDR3 - 1333 Mhz
BANK 1/DIMM0: 4 GB - DDR3 - 1333 Mhz
BANK 0/DIMM1: 8 GB - DDR3 - 1333 Mhz
BANK 1/DIMM1: 8 GB - DDR3 - 1333 Mhz
Geekbench 4 shows and memory bandwitdh at 15.4 GB/sec for Single-Core and 16.6 GB/sec for Multi-Core
(Full results at : https://browser.geekbench.com/v4/cpu/101...)
The good configuration to exploit the Dual Channel to get the best performance is “by DIMM” meaning to have same RAM sizes in same DIMM number.
Daniel
Bu yanıt yardımcı oldu mu?
Oy verildi
Geri al
Puan
23
İptal
Bu yoruma uygun yeri bulmak için bu konuyu kaydırın. Ardından, taşımak için "Bu yazıya yorum ekle"ye tıklayın.
2 Yorum
my test results with 2019 iMac 8GB and 32GB
configurations (note: the bottom slot is Bank 0 the top slot is Bank 3)
#1: 8GB
Bank 0 Channel A DIMM 0 4GB
Bank 1 Channel A DIMM 1
Bank 2 Channel B DIMM 0 4GB
Bank 3 Channel B DIMM 1
#2: 32GB
Bank 0 Channel A DIMM 0 16GB
Bank 1 Channel A DIMM 1
Bank 2 Channel B DIMM 0 16GB
Bank 3 Channel B DIMM 1
#3: 40GB
Bank 0 Channel A DIMM 0 16GB
Bank 1 Channel A DIMM 1 4GB
Bank 2 Channel B DIMM 0 16GB
Bank 3 Channel B DIMM 1 4GB
#4: 40GB
Bank 0 Channel A DIMM 0 16GB
Bank 1 Channel A DIMM 1 16GB
Bank 2 Channel B DIMM 0 4GB
Bank 3 Channel B DIMM 1 4GB
test results Novabench - each test run three times and since results vary a bit, I am reporting an approximate range (for RAM test only)
#1 24.5K to 26.5K MB/s
#2 27K to 29.5K MB/s
#3 26.5K to 27.5K MB/s
#4 16.8K to 17.2K MB/s
test results Geekbench 5 (single/multi-core)
#1 1218-1220/5510-6856
#2 1310-1326/7850-8220
#3 1187-1197/7760-7880
#4 1187-1192/6250-7750
Avi Carmi tarafından
I tested a mix of two kinds of memory sticks with different size capacities and different benchmarks results
A) 2x4G Original Apple SK Hynix
B) 2x16GB Kinsgton HyperX Impact KHX2666C15S4/16G
my analysis:
the Apple Hynix is slower than the Kingston HyperX Impact as can be seen by comparing #1 and #2, where #2 was the fastest of all.
for the mix, #3 where the sticks are staggered was the fastest, but not as fast as #2 (apparently the Apple sticks being slower, bring the overall speed down???)
#4 mix (which if I am not mistaken is what Apple recommends) was the slowest by far in Novabench, 16K vs 26K MB/s, yet about the same as #3 mix in single-core Geekbench and bit faster than #1 in multi-core
see https://discussions.apple.com/thread/251... for what Apple recommended
for a while, I was running #2 with the 32GB Kingston, however, it seems that apps now require more and more memory, and so I just switched to configuration #3 with 40GB
hope this helps
Avi Carmi tarafından